We expect the market to roll over in the next few weeks, with the coming Q1 earnings season. We normally don’t make such short term calls, but we feel strongly that this bear market rally is very close to over and its time to cut back on equity exposure, or go short.
Our rationale – we expect Q1, Q2, 2020 and ’21 earnings to come in much much lower than the market currently expects.
“For Q1 2020, the estimated earnings decline for the S&P 500 is -10%. If -10% is the actual decline for the quarter, it will mark the largest year-over-year decline in earnings reported by the index since Q3 2009 (-15.7%).”
We at MWCM expect the earnings decline will be far greater than 10% for Q1 and will be well below consensus for the full year.
We take the view that the current ‘bottom-up’ market expectations of a 17% gain for the year are completely unfounded.
“Industry analysts in aggregate predict the S&P 500 will see an 17.8% increase in price over the next twelve months. …..On April 8, the bottom- up target price for the S&P 500 was 3238.62, which was 17.8% above the closing price of 2749.98.”
With over half the world’s population in lockdown and no clarity on how we will deal with this virus risk for the next 12 months, the expectation above is just completely bogus. At least in our view. It indicates to us that the consensus is absolutely clueless in how to price in the sort of demand destruction we are witnessing.
It simply doesn’t make any sense for the consensus to be expecting revenue growth for Q12020 of 1%, year on year. Given GDP will likely to show a large negative print.
Lets focus on the facts – a dose of reality:
- Over half the world’s population is in lockdown and there may only be an easing of this towards May
- The virus threat will remain – we should expect a start/stop economy for the next 12 months at least.
- Unemployment in the US will likely hit 15% by the end of April 2020. It is likely to go marginally higher yet. This is depression type levels.
- Demand for autos will down something like 40–60% for H1 – all big ticket purchases will be similarly impacted.
- Consumer sentiment has fallen to levels seen in 2008. Will it fall below those levels? Very likely, as the lockdowns drag on
- Leading indicators – such as ECRI, PMI, ISM are all at levels BELOW that of 2008/09, reflecting a significant contraction in GDP.
- GDP could contract 5-10% depending on how the lockdown is managed
- The US banks, as well as those globally, will need to increase loan loss reserves massively. In the US alone loan loss reserves will need to increase to around USD100bn – see GS expectations.
- Rates are already at 0% and 30 year bond yields for the US, Japan and Europe are all well below 1%. – and we haven’t even started the real recession yet.
- Corporate leverage in the US is at record highs and we should expect to see huge number of BBB credits being downgraded..
- Stock buybacks and dividends will fall dramatically – either enforced or voluntarily. Buybacks have been a substantial driver of EPS growth in the past – and that will now be lost.
- The US equity markets came into this crisis expensive and are even more expensive now.
Our expectation is that we will have a U/L shaped recovery and that EPS could decline by 50-60% for the full year 2020. This would make the S&P500 expensive, trading at over 30x. And even if you don’t believe earnings will fall that much, that market is expensive on trailing valuations……
But, the BULL argument will be that the Fed and Treasury will, like the ECB and BOJ save the day and stabilise the markets. Well, its seems that is the current consensus of the market and being priced in.
The Fed has pumped some USD4trl into the economy. It first reduced rates to 0%, launched the Commercial Paper Funding Facility to backstop Investment Grade issuers, and more recently even High Yield. The Treasury also announced a usd2trl CARES act as part of the fiscal response.
The actions of the various central banks and governments has supported the credit market and prevented a meltdown of Great Depression proportions. But it does not generate earnings. It doesn’t create economic growth. See Japan as an example, that has been in a slump for decades, even with huge amounts of government stimulus.
Rather, it has provided the plaster on the festering wound of an over leveraged economy that is in lockdown and stalled. The stimulus won’t be enough. It is only a stabilising force on what is the initial market shock. We still need to go through the process of dealing with the wider impact of the lockdowns and the bankruptcies that are sure to follow.
But this is not to say there aren’t going to be some great opportunities ahead. Personally, I expect the environment should yield 3-5x type returns over a few years, if it plays out the way I expect. That what recessions are all about.They provide investors with excellent entry points. Right now patience is key – one has to sit back, do one’s research and wait for the right entry points. And most importantly, be safe.